PDA

View Full Version : If you missed McGrew's - Brady Watson - IBILD.com Laser Scanning



Brady Watson
06-05-2015, 09:27 AM
I know a lot of you wanted to attend McGrew's Camp last month, but were unable to. I thought I would post a little project I showed during my presentation. I've been getting a lot of requests for 3D printing applications, which has much higher requirements for clean/closed/water-tight data. In this example I will show how the data can be used for both 3D CNC routing applications as well as 3D printing, although I must admit my 3D printer is just a 'cheapie' so the actual data is better than the print shows.

I thought I would pick something that most of us use on a daily basis - In this case, a 12' tape measure. The original had quite a bit of black rubber (which is very diffuse - it absorbs the light) in addition to some dayglow coloring, which in contrast to the black would scatter a lot of light while scanning. I elected to paint each half to make sure I got good data. This is sometimes a necessary evil with scanning - and in most cases it is OK since we will be able to make duplicates once we have the data anyway.

I started by disassembling the tape and putting the components aside. Each half was scanned on all sides. Some models have deep cavernous features that don't have a clear line of sight, making 100% coverage of the scan tough or impossible. This is where software comes into the picture to enable hole filling etc. I filled in some areas in Aspire that were part of the injection molding process and not necessary for the wood variant. Some of the features on this part were very tiny, such as the little alignment bars at only 0.018" thick, which luckily didn't snap off while machining!

Once the data was ready for digital fabrication, each half was brought into Aspire. Rather than use the data as-is, I elected to add a little flair to one of the case halves using the 3D tools in Aspire. A few lines and a cross-section and a lovely little weave was added for no additional machining cost. Each half was toolpathed and setup to run on the ShopBot. Each half was machined on 2 sides in maple (color doesn't match on them...I just used scrap I had laying around in the shop). I roughed out with an 1/8" and finished with a 1/16" ball. I drilled the screw holes by hand because I wanted to test fit them - but could have done this on the Bot as well.

When machining was complete, I test fit the ones off the machine with the corresponding plastic original. It was a *perfect* fit!!! No file or Dremel work! Now I don't care if any of you are not impressed by this, but I sure am!!! I wanted to seal the halves before moisture warped them, so I put some Watco oil on each half to seal it. Now, there is a reason they don't make tape measures 100% out of wood. If you look at one of the pics, you'll see that the forked mandrel that holds the spring for the tape retraction is glued...I tried to keep it from twisting and snapping, but it just couldn't handle the stress/twisting. I had to glue it. While gluing it (Q-Bond) a little dripped on the tape roll and locked it in place - so the tape won't go in & out now - but that's OK. ALL of the original hardware fit right onto the wood one perfectly. The little detent switch that locks the tape glides effortlessly.

Using the same data, I filled in all of the holes and 3D printed it in plastic. Due to time constraints I just printed the whole thing out solid (20% in-fill) to show how the same data can be used in other ways...So once you invest in 3D data, it's the gift that keeps on giving. You can use the original to make duplicates, or add a little flair to the project. It is also possible to use the data for 3D visualization or to make derivative works to stretch the product line with a similar motif etc.



-B

Brady Watson
06-05-2015, 09:28 AM
More pics.................

Brady Watson
06-05-2015, 09:28 AM
more pics.......

mtylerfl
06-05-2015, 10:27 AM
Pretty Cool, Brady!

pappybaynes
06-05-2015, 01:46 PM
Pretty Cool, Brady!

That is sweet Brady!
Dick

Simops
06-05-2015, 06:23 PM
Excellent Brady.......this is what I'm starting to get my teeth into.......Both the subtractive process CNC and additive process 3D printing. Both distinct but complementary!
I just couldn't get my head around 3D drawing and design in Aspire.....not yet anyway. So I settled for DesignSpark Mechanical from RS parts.....the push / pull method was for me more intuitive process to use in 3D design. I haven't done scanning and importing the part that way yet and maybe this is where Aspire will shine once I get to doing scanning.......scanning is another field in itself!!

By all means keep posting your efforts in this area with some tech info......

Cheers

Brady Watson
06-05-2015, 08:38 PM
Michael & Dick - Thanks for the kudos.

Mr Tavcar - Thank you as well. Yes, it is exciting stuff. Scanning is in many ways a lot like CNC. It's part science and part art/skill. The 3D printing stuff is pretty exciting too. For me, it has allowed me to look at 3D in new ways and while the methods for fabrication are different, the files can for the most part be shared between additive and subtractive processes. 3D printing requires that the model be 100% watertight or there will be problems slicing the model or it will do strange things when printing that the slicer doesn't show. For 3D CNC routing, all you really need is a skin or simple surface that is perpendicular to the Z axis. Aspire/VCP etc will make the edges straight walled and you can machine it as is.

More later...

-B

myxpykalix
06-05-2015, 09:27 PM
That looks pretty cool! It may not be the most durable tape measure you have but one thing you can say is....ain't nobody else got one like it!

don62
06-06-2015, 12:42 AM
Brady, great and informative, as usual! The 4views jpg looks like rhino drawing, did you do all the design in aspire, or the cleanup in rhino? Thank, don

Simops
06-06-2015, 03:46 AM
Brady....with the 3D printing....are you using ABS or PLA? What's your preferred filament type?

Cheers

Brady Watson
06-06-2015, 08:40 AM
Hey Michael,
PLA is by far the most user friendly material. It seems to produce the most reliable prints with the least number of issues. However, ABS is much stronger when it comes to structural or functional parts. You can make some pretty strong parts with PLA, but ounce for ounce, ABS is stronger. I use a heated bed for all of my prints to help it to stay put.

I've printed PLA, ABS, PET, Bronze-Fill, Ninja-Flex rubber - soft & hard, carbon-fiber filled filament and a couple of others. I am sure at some point I'll build my own and do it 'my way' - like everything else :) I'd like to have a larger build volume and give up some resolution for speed and filament volume. A 0.2-0.5 mm layer range would be pretty sweet for larger parts.

I'm actually working on a project now where the parts are ABS to begin with, and would be a good candidate for ABS printing if I could do them in one piece. It is possible to 'tile' the prints, much like we do for CNC, but a 'monolith' is stronger than a multi-piece part that has to be cemented together. The part may also be ripe for vacuum-forming, so I will be trying that before I try printing it. Production time is WAY faster with the vacuum forming avenue. I just don't know yet if some of the complicated features are the part are possible to resolve with VF since the wall thickness is around 3mm. We shall see as time allows.

-B

LDA
07-07-2015, 01:42 PM
Brady, what 3D scanner, 3d printer are you using? The scanning gave really good detail, so I am curious which one you used.

Thanks,

Brady Watson
07-07-2015, 02:09 PM
The scanner is a proprietary setup that I built in house. The printer is just a garden variety UM2.

-B

Brian Harnett
07-07-2015, 09:23 PM
Really awesome stuff, when I look back I cant believe how far we have come in such a short time with technology and it just keeps expanding thanks for staying on top of the wave Brady.

Brady Watson
07-08-2015, 08:48 AM
Thanks Brian. I try to keep on top of the technology. The goal is perfect scans right off the machine...I think I am there this year. It isn't a cheap undertaking...

-B